Articles
HOUSING RIGHTS OF HEIRS OF THE FOURTH LINE
https://doi.org/10.31652/2786-6068-2023-3-12-17Published 2024-01-31
Keywords
- legal heirs,
- residential rights of the testator's family members,
- Escheat,
- local self-government bodies
How to Cite
HOUSING RIGHTS OF HEIRS OF THE FOURTH LINE. (2024). Public Management and Law History Theory Practice, 3, 17-22. https://doi.org/10.31652/2786-6068-2023-3-12-17
Abstract
The article clarifies the specifics of the legal status of the testator's family members - the fourth line of heirs by law. The lack of a legal definition of the concept of "member of the testator's family" and different interpretations of this concept in family, housing, and labor law create difficulties for this category of persons when inheriting by law. The interested person must prove the actual composition in a court of law, the presence of which allows him to be considered a fourth-line heir by law. Unlike heirs, whose status is determined by birth or marriage certificates issued by state registration authorities and testifying to the existence of family or marital relations, the legal status of a person recognized as a family member in court is not final and may change. The court's decision to recognize a person as a member of the testator's family may be canceled by the court of appeal or cassation instance. The problems that arise when such a decision is annulled, if the quasi-heir has sold real estate to a third party, are clarified. It was noted that the absence of a legal definition of the term «member of the testator's family» necessitates the need for the interested person to prove in court the actual composition, the presence of which allows him to be considered a fourth-line heir by law. Unlike heirs, whose status is determined by birth or marriage certificates issued by state registration authorities and testifying to the existence of family or marital relations, the legal position of a person recognized as a family member in court may change if such a decision is overturned by a court of appeal or cassation instance. The need to impose a ban on the alienation of immovable property within a certain period of time, if this property has passed to the heir of the fourth line, is substantiated. Such an amendment will limit the owner's right to dispose of immovable property, but will contribute to the protection of both private and public interests after the opening of the inheritance. In particular, it will protect the property rights of fifth-line heirs or local self-government bodies when the inheritance is recognized as dead, as well as exclude unjustified enrichment of a person who did not have the right to alienate objects of inheritance.Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
- Haliantych, M., Zaika, Y. & Popovych, T. (2022). Legal nature of the contract for housing and utility services. Entrepreneurship, economy and Law. Vol. 2, 40–47. [in Ukrainian]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32849/2663-5313/2022.2.05
- Zaika, Y.O. (2020). Directions of updating the inheritance legislation of Ukraine. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine. Vol. 27. 1. 84–99. [in Ukrainian]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.37635/jnalsu.27(1).2020.84-99
- Zaika, Y.O. (2021). The Right to Dispose of the Property in the Human Rights System Current challenges of Human Rights, Rule of Law and Democracy Ed. by Robert Tabaszewski, Wydawnictwo KUL. Lublin. 213-232. [in Ukrainian].
- Zaika, Y.O., Kukhariev, O.Ye., Skrypnyk, V.L. & Mytnyk, A.A. (2021). Peculiarities of Protection of Rights and Interests of Heirs: Theoretical Aspects. International Journal of Criminology and Sociology. Vol. 10, 355–362. [in Ukrainian]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.6000/1929-4409.2021.10.43
- Zaika, YU.O. (2021). Mekhanizm rehulyuvannya maynovykh vidnosyn, shcho vynykayut' pislya vidkryttya spadshchyny [Mechanism of regulation of property relations arising after the discovery of inheritance]. Pidpryyemnytstvo, hospodarstvo i pravo.Vol. 6, 23-28. [in Ukrainian]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32849/2663-5313/2021.6.04
- Zaika, YU.O. (2022). Pravo na prodazh spadshchynyyu Spadkove pravo: kriz' pryzmu sudovoyi praktyky [The right to sell an inheritance. Inheritance law: through the prism of judicial practice]: monohrafiya. za red. I. V. Spasybo-Fatyeyevoyi. Kharkiv: EKUS. 124–148. [in Ukrainian].
- Zaika, YU.O. (2019). Yurydychni fakty u spadkovomu pravi [Legal facts in inheritance law]. Novitni pidkhody do rozuminnya yurydychnykh faktiv u mekhanizmi pravovoho rehulyuvannya pryvatnykh vidnosyn. Kyyiv: NDI PrPiP im. akad. F. H. Burchaka NAPrN Ukrayiny. 105-123. [in Ukrainian].
- Zaika, YU.O. & Kukharev, O.YE. (2022). Novelizatsiya norm spadkovoho prava [Amendment of the norms of inheritance law]. Rekodyfikatsiya tsyvil'noho zakonodavstva Ukrayiny: vyklyky chasu: monohrafiya Odesa: Vydavnychyy dim «Hel'vetyka». 308 –333. [in Ukrainian].
- Kossak, V.M., Zaika, YU.O., Kvit, N.M. & Mykhayliv M.O. (2020). Osnovni napryamy novelizatsiyi spadkovoho prava v umovakh onovlennya Tsyvil'noho kodeksu Ukrayiny [The main directions of the amendment of inheritance law in the conditions of updating the Civil Code of Ukraine]. Onovlennya tsyvil'noho kodeksu Ukrayiny: formuvannya pidkhodiv: monohrafiya. Odesa: Vyd. dim. «Hel'vetyka». 548-609. [in Ukrainian].
- Pro notariat [About the notary]: Zakon Ukrayiny vid 02 ver. 1993 r. № 3425-XII. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3425-12#Text [in Ukrainian].
- Pravo vlasnosti na zhytlo v Ukrayini: doktryna ta realizatsiya [Home ownership in Ukraine: doctrine and implementation] (2016). : monohrafiya / za zah. red. akademikiv Krupchana, O.D. & Lutsya, V.V. Kyyiv: N DI PrPiP im. akad. F. H. Burchaka NAPrN Ukrayiny. S. 247. [in Ukrainian].
- Ryms'ke pravo : kriz' pryzmu tradytsiy i sudovoyi praktyky [Roman law: through the prism of traditions and judicial practice]: monohrafiya / za red. prof. Spasybo-Fatyeyevoyi, I.V. Kharkiv : EKUS. S. 512. [in Ukrainian].
- Rishennya Konstytutsiynoho Sudu Ukrayiny [Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine]. vid 03 chervnya 1999 r. shchodo ofitsiynoho tlumachennya termina «chlen sim'yi». Sprava 1-8/99. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v005p710-99#Text [in Ukrainian].
- Spesivtsev, D. (2022). Kontseptual'ni problemy pravovoho rehulyuvannya tsyvil'nykh vidnosyn v umovakh viyny [Conceptual problems of legal regulation of civil relations in conditions of war] : monohrafiya. Luts'k: Zavzhdy Poruch. S. 248. [in Ukrainian].
- Suchasni tendentsiyi rozvytku spadkovoho prava (porivnyal'no-pravove doslidzhennya) [Modern trends in the development of inheritance law (comparative legal research)] (2015) : monohrafiya / Zaika, YU.O., Soltys, N.B., Protsenko, V.V. & Ryabokon', YE.O.; vidp. red. akademik NAPrN Ukrayiny V. V. Luts'. Kyyiv: NDI pryvatnoho prava i pidpryyemnytstva im. akad. F. H. Burchaka NAPrN Ukrayiny. S. 248. [in Ukrainian].
- Ukrayins'ke tsyvil'ne pravo [Ukrainian civil law] (2014): navch. posib. 3-tye vyd. pererob. ta dop. Kyyiv: «Tsentr uchbovoyi literatury». S. 358. [in Ukrainian].
- Kharkivs'ka tsyvilistychna shkola: mezhi spadkovoho prava [Kharkiv civil school: limits of inheritance law] (2016): monohrafiya. Kharkiv: Pravo. S. 608. [in Ukrainian].