Keywords
How to Cite
Abstract
The purpose of this article is to analyse the practice of defection as an illegal emigration mechanism. The set of tasks is outlined by the questions about the explanatory schemes used by the "fugitives", as well as the study of the reaction of state authorities and repressive organs to fugitive practices. The research methodology is based on a combination of interdisciplinary methods, including critical discourse analysis, narrative analysis, historical-comparative and historical-systemic methods. The scientific novelty of the study is that the defections and non-returns of the perestroika period have never been considered as a social phenomenon and social practices, as they were not scenarios through which the path of reforms was paved. Conclusions. The defections continued to be a channel of emigration throughout the period of so-called perestroika. These were planned actions included both in the practices of legal border crossing and in criminal practices related to the hijacking of aircraft. People of different ages, nationalities, professions, places of residence, and family status have resorted to defection. A common feature of their behaviour was a deep distrust of the authorities, such that they did not perceive any changes and reforms as possible or real.The explanatory schemes used by the fugitives depended on whether the attempt at illegal emigration was successful or unsuccessful. During the period under study, the KGB's rhetoric and practice of preventing defections from the Ukrainian SSR changed significantly. If at the beginning of perestroika, information on defectors submitted to the Central Committee of the CP(U) ended with a promise to make efforts to return them to their homeland, at the end of the period, they were reported as "working to clarify the circumstances and motives."Another sign of the times was the fact that the image of a defector began to be formed not according to the templates of an "enemy of the people", "traitor – member of a spy network", but according to formulas for devaluing the social importance of the offender. Fugitives were described in both official reports and the press as petty criminals, fraudsters, alcoholics, and people with mental disorders.
References
Alidin, V. (1977). Kontrrazvedyvatelnaya rabota na kanale vremennogo vyezda sovetskikh grazhdan za granitsu. [Counter-intelligence work on the channel of temporary departure of Soviet citizens abroad]. Moskva. 181 s.
Arkhipova, E. (2008). Nekotorye aspekty razvitiya sovetskogo vyezdnogo turizma v 1980–1991 gg. (na primere turistskogo obmena s kapitalisticheskimi stranami). [Some aspects of the development of Soviet outbound tourism in 1980-1991 (on the example of tourist exchange with capitalist countries)]. Sovremennye problemy servisa i turizma. 1. 36–43.
Artemov, A. (2015). Obraz perestroyki v 1990 godu: protivorechiya vospriyatiya (na materiale sotsiologicheskogo issledovaniya).[ The image of perestroika in 1990: contradictions of perception (on the material of sociological research).] Vestnik YuUrGU. Seriya «Sotsialno-gumanitarnye nauki». 15 (2). 91-96.
Chandler, А. (1998). Institutions of isolation: border controls in the Soviet Union and its successor states, 1917-1993. McGill-Queen's University Press Montreal & Kingston London Buffalo, 222 р.
Chetyrina, N. (2007). Zagranichnyy turizm v sovetskoe vremya [Foreign tourism in Soviet times ]// Migratsii i turizm v Rossii / pod red. Yu.A. Polyakova. Moskva. 348–355.
Drozdov, S. (2009). Vozdushnye piraty Strany Sovetov. [Air pirates of the Soviet country]. Aviatsiya i vremya, 3. 28–31.
Ferro, M., Afanasev, Yu. (Redaktory). (1989). Opyt slovarya novogo politicheskogo myshleniya. [Experiencing the vocabulary of new political thinking]. Moskva. 560 s.
Gorsuch, A. (2011). All This Is Your World: Soviet Tourist at Home and Abroad after Stalin. N.Y.: Oxford Univ. Press, 272 р.
HDA SBU – Haluzevyi derzhavnyi arkhiv Sluzhby bezpeky Ukrainy [The Branch State Archive of the Security Service of Ukraine.]
Harbar, H. (2005). Ideolohichnyi kharakter zarubizhnoho (vyiznoho) turyzmu v Mykolaivskii oblasti 70-kh - pershoi polovyny 80-kh rr. [The ideological background of foreign (outbound) tourism in the Mykolaiv region in the 1970s and first half of the 1980s.]. Humanitarnyi zhurnal, 5, 68–73.
Kabakov, A.(1990). Nevozvrashchenets. [A non-returnee]. Moskva. «Dialog kultur». 128 s
Kizima, M.,Kizima, S. (2018). Osobennosti turizma i zagranichnykh puteshestviy v Sovetskom Soyuze. [The specific features of tourism and foreign travel in the Soviet Union]. SONAR-2050. https://www.sonar2050.org/publications/turizm-v-sovetskom-soyuze/
Kozovoi, A. (2011). Eye to Eye with the «Main Enemy»: Soviet Youth Travel to the United States. Ab Imperio, 2, 221-237.
Krasnov, V. (2018). Soviet Defector: The KGB Wanted List. Hoover Press, 264 р.
Kryminalnyi kodeks URSR. (1960). [The Criminal Code of the Ukrainian RSR]. https://ips.ligazakon.net/document/view/kd0006?an=480572&ed=1960_12_28
Lavreniuk, V. (1990). Chy vazhko vkrasty litak. [Whether it is difficult to steal a plane]. Chornomorska komuna, 10 lypnia, 4.
Levashov, E. (Redaktor). (1997). Novye slova i znacheniya. Slovar-spravochnik po materialam pressy 80-kh godov. [New words and meanings. Dictionary-guide based on the press materials of the 80s]. Sankt-Peterburg, 904 s.
Maksimov, V. (Redaktor). (1992). Slovar perestroyki. [A Dictionary of Perestroika]. Sankt-Peterburg, 253 s.
Markozova, O. (2016). Zminy u rozuminni zhyttievoho uspikhu osobystosti v period perebudovy. [Changes in the understanding of personal success during perestroika]. Visnyk Natsionalnoho universytetu «Iurydychna akademiia Ukrainy imeni Yaroslava Mudroho», 1 (28), 69-77.
Osnovnye pravila povedeniya sovetskikh grazhdan. vyezzhayushchikh v kapitalisticheskiye i razvivayushchiyesya strany; Osnovnye pravila povedeniya sovetskikh grazhdan. vyezzhayushchikh v sotsialisticheskiye strany (2005). [ Basic rules of behaviour for Soviet citizens. travelling to capitalist and developing countries; Basic rules of behaviour for Soviet citizens. travelling to socialist countries]. / Lubyanka — Staraya ploshchad: Sekretnye dokumenty TsK KPSS i KGB o repressiyakh 1937—1990 godov v SSSR: Sb. dokumentov. Moskva: Posev. 240 s. http://krotov.info/lib_sec/12_l/lub/yanka.htm
Popov, O. (2009). Arkhivni dzherela z istorii vyiznoho turyzmu v SRSR(na prykladi Krymu). [The archival sources on the history of outbound tourism in the USSR (on the example of Crimea)]. Aktualni problemy vitchyznianoi ta vsesvitnoi istorii. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats. Kharkiv, 12, 290-295.
Postanovleniye Soveta Ministrov SSSR ot 16 avgusta 1989 g. № 661 «O sovershenstvovanii poryadka vyezda za granitsu po sluzhebnym delam» ["On improving the procedure for travelling abroad on official business"] https://www.economics.kiev.ua/download/ZakonySSSR/data01/tex11237.htm
Postanovleniye Soveta Ministrov SSSR ot 27 sentyabrya 1988 g. № 1119 «O merakh. napravlennykh na uproshcheniye poryadka vyezda grazhdan SSSR za granitsu» ["On Measures to Simplify the Procedure for the Departure of Citizens of the USSR Abroad"] https://www.economics.kiev.ua/download/ZakonySSSR/data01/tex11482.htm
Postanovleniye Verkhovnogo Soveta SSSR ot 20 maya 1991 g. № 2178 «O vvedenii v deystviye zakona SSSR "O poryadke vyezda iz Soyuza Sovetskikh Sotsialisticheskikh respublik i vezda v Soyuz Sovetskikh Sotsialisticheskikh respublik grazhdan SSSR» ["On the Enactment of the Law of the USSR 'On the Procedure for the Departure from the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics and Entry into the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics of Citizens of the USSR'"] https://www.economics.kiev.ua/download/ZakonySSSR/data01/tex10225.htm
Rajewsky, А. (2000). Changes in the Russian Terminology of Economic Law since Perestroika. Munchen, 208 р.
Raleigh, D. (2012). «On the Other Side of the Wall, Things Are Even Better». Travel and the Opening of the Soviet Union: The Oral Evidence. Ab Imperio, 4, 373-399.
Riehle, K. (2020). Soviet Defectors: Revelations of Renegade Intelligence Officers, 1924-1954. Edinburgh University Press, 336 p.
Salnikova, A., Gerasimova, E. (2016). About some cases of "non-return" as a special form ofemigration from the ussr during the period of "the coldwar". Man in India, 96 (3), 787-793.
Scott, E. (2023). Defectors: How the illicit Fight of Soviet Citizens Built the Borders of the Cold War World. Oxford University Press, 304 p.
Soviet Farmer Flies to Sweden, Asks for Asylum. (1987). LosAngeles Times, May 28. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1987-05-28-mn-3261-story.html
Tarasov, V. (2016) Obraz perebudovy (1985-1991) v suchasnii istoriohrafii: problema terminolohii ta interpretatsii [The image of perestroika (1985-1991) in modern historiography: the problem of terminology and interpretation]/ Za red. prof. Olhy Koliastruk / Vyd. 2-he, dopov. Kharkiv: «Rarytety Ukrainy», 120 s.
TsDAHO Ukrainy – Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv hromadskykh obiednan Ukrainy. [The Central State Archive of Public Organisations of Ukraine].
TsDAMLM Ukrainy – Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv-muzei literatury ta mystetstva Ukrainy [The Central State Archive-Museum of Literature and Art of Ukraine].
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2023 Olena Stiazhkina