Keywords
How to Cite
Abstract
The aim of the article is to analyze the emergence of Soviet state policy on shoe recycling in the early 1930s, focusing on the Ukrainian SSR as a case study. Scientific novelty: While a growing body of literature addresses Soviet daily life, materiality, consumption, and repair practices, the area of shoe recycling remains underexplored at both the Union and Republican levels. Examining this niche aspect offers insight into the complexities of Soviet economic strategies and ideological narratives around resourcefulness, self-sufficiency and waste recycling. Research methodology: The study draws on previously unexplored Ukrainian archival materials, statistical collections of USSR and Soviet legislation, enabling a comprehensive and multi-dimensional analysis of the economic, social, and political implications of shoe recycling. The article also includes a comparative analysis of shoe recycling practices in the USSR and Germany during the 1920s and 1930s. This comparative angle sheds light on how both countries—facing resource scarcity and aim for self-sufficiency - leveraged recycling within their leather and footwear industries, albeit with differing ideological drivers and practices. Conclusions: In this article, it is argued that Soviet shoe recycling was more than just a practical response to resource scarcity; it was also ideologically motivated, aiming to demonstrate the advantages of the socialist system. The shoe recycling policy became an essential component of a broader waste reutilization strategy that began in the early 1920s. The so-called "shoe problem" served as a catalyst for advancements in science, technology, and alternative materials, as well as for the establishment of a state-led shoe repair program, a key element in the recycling process. At the same time, the ambitious plans of the Soviet government faced implementation challenges due to shortages in the Soviet economy.
References
Bjudzhety semejnyh fabrichno-zavodskih rabochih SSSR. [Budgets of family factory workers in the USSR.]. (1933). URL: https://istmat.org/files/uploads/47196/rgae_1562.329.62_l.12.pdf [in Russian].
Borysenko, M. (2008). Pobut miskykh meshkantsiv Ukrainy v 30-kh rokakh ХХ stolittiaх [Life of urban residents of Ukraine in the 30s of the 20th centuries]. Etnichna istoriia narodiv Yevropy, vyp. 24. 12–18. [in Ukrainian].
Dekret Vserossijskogo Central'nogo Ispolnitel'nogo Komiteta. O priznanii udarnymi rabot po zagotovke zhivotnogo syr'ja, kozhi, pushniny, kozovchiny, shhetiny, volosa, shersti, rogov i kopyt. [Decree of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee. On the recognition of shock work on the procurement of animal raw materials, leather, fur, goat skin, bristles, hair, wool, horns and hooves].1918. URL: https://istmat.org/node/46630 [in Russian].
Gerasimova, E., Chuikina, S. (2009). The Repair Society. Russian Studies in History, 48(1). 58-74. [in English].
Golubev, A. (2020). The Things of Life: Materiality in Late Soviet Russia. New York: Cornell University Press 220 p. [in English].
Gurova, O. (2005). Ideologija potreblenija v sovetskom obshhestve [Ideology of consumption in Soviet society], Sociologicheskij zhurnal vyp. 4. 117-131. URL: https://www.journal-socjournal.ru/index.php/socjour/article/view/894 [in Russian]
Eaton, A. (2004). Daily Life in the Soviet Union. Santa Barbara: Greenwood. 344 p. [in English].
Fitzpatrick, S. (2008). Everyday stalinism: Ordinary life in extraordinary times: Soviet Russia in the 1930s. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 312 p. [in English].
Ispytatel'naja stancija kozhevennoj promyshlennosti [Leather Industry Testing Station]. 1927. URL: https://istmat.org/node/29367. [in Russian].
Itogi perepisi skota na 1 fevralja 1932 goda. Vypusk 1. Chislennost' skota po evropejskoj chasti RSFSR, Ukrainskoj SSR i Belarusskoj SSR [Livestock census results for February 1, 1932. Issue 1. The number of cattle in the European part of the RSFSR, the Ukrainian SSR and the Belarusian SSR]. (1932). Moskva: Sojuzorguchet. 41 s. [in Russian].
Kiaer, C., Naiman, E. (2005). Everyday Life in Early Soviet Russia: Taking the Revolution Inside. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 320 p. [in English].
Kozhevennaja i obuvnaja promyshlennost'. 1928. Pjatiletnij plan razvitija narodnogo hozjajstva SSSR (pervaja pjatiletka). [Leather and footwear industry. Five-year plan for national economic development of the USSR (First Five-year plan)]. URL: https://istmat.org/node/41351 [in Russian].
Krebs, S., Weber, H. (2021). The Persistence of Technology. Histories of Repair, Reuse and Disposal. Bielefeld: Verlag. 287 p. [in English].
Kornai, J. (1980). Economics of Shortage. Amsterdam: North Holland Publishing Company. 631 p. [in English].
Movchan, O. M. (2011). Povsiakdenne zhyttia robitnykiv USRR. 1920-ti rr. [Everyday life of workers of the USSR. 1920s]. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy NAN Ukrainy. 312 s.
O snabzhenii rabochih proizvodstvennoj odezhdoj i special'nymi vidami odezhdy i obuvi [On the supply of workers with industrial clothing and special types of clothing and footwear]. 1931. URL: https://istmat.org/node/54880 [in Russian].
Osnovnye pokazateli razvitija narodnogo hozjajstva sojuznyh respublik. Chast' I Strana Sovetov za 50 let (Sbornik statisticheskih materialov) [Main indicators of development of the national economy of the union republics. Part I. The country of the Soviets for 50 years (Collection of statistical materials)]. 1967. URL: https://istmat.org/node/17051 [in Russian].
O rekvizicii na stancijah i pristanjah vseh manufakturnyh i obuvnyh tovarov, ne vykuplennyh so skladov v techenie dvuh sutok [On the requisition at stations and docks of all manufactured and footwear goods not redeemed from warehouses within two days]. URL: https://istmat.org/node/28128 [in Russian].
Osherovich, M. (2020). How People Live in Soviet Russia: Impressions from a Journey. Canada: Kashtan Press. 342 p. [in English].
O vypolnenii postanovlenija CK o razvertyvanii seti masterskih po vypolneniju individual'nyh zakazov odezhdy i obuvi. (Prinjato Politbjuro CK VKP(b) 16.VI.32 g.). Prilozhenie № 7 k p. 75/17 pr. PB № 104 [On the implementation of the Central Committee resolution on the development of a network of workshops for the fulfillment of individual orders for clothing and footwear. (Adopted by the Politburo of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) on 16.VI.32). Appendix No. 7 to paragraph 75/17 of the pr. PB No. 104]. 1932. URL: https://istmat.org/node/55944 [In Russian].
Perga, T. (2023). Waste for the Soviet Economy: Recycling of Rags in Ukraine in the 1920s. Worldwide Waste: Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 6(1). 4. https://doi.org/10.5334/wwwj.97 [in English].
Postanovlenie Vysshego Soveta Narodnogo Hozjajstva i Narodnogo Komissariata Prodovol'stvija. O tverdyh cenah na kozhu [Resolution of the Supreme Council of the National Economy and the People's Commissariat of Food. On fixed prices for leather]. 1918. URL: https://istmat.org/node/31664 [in Russian].
Postanovlenie Vysshego Soveta Narodnogo Hozjajstva. Ob uchete gotovyh kozh, vvozimyh iz-za granicy [Resolution of the Supreme Council of the National Economy. On the accounting of finished leather imported from abroad]. 1918. URL: https://istmat.org/node/31493 [in Russian].
Postanovlenie Vysshego Soveta Narodnogo Hozjajstva. O Glavnom i gubernskih komitetah kozhevennoj promyshlennosti [Resolution of the Supreme Council of the National Economy. On the Main and Provincial Committees of the Leather Industry]. 1919. URL: https://istmat.org/node/35543 [in Russian].
Postoly, lapti, khodaky: Yake vzuttia nosyly nashi predky [Boots, slippers, walkers: What kind of shoes did our ancestors wear]. 2024. URL: https://localhistory.org.ua/rubrics/strii/pletene-vzuttia/ [in Ukrainian]
Pristed, В.В. (2020). Point of no return: Soviet paper reuse, 1932–1945. Business History 54(5). 946-962. https://doi.org/10.1080/00076791.2020.1842875 [in English].
Promyshlennost' [Industry]. 1925. URL:
https://istmat.org/files/uploads/32172/ctat._ezh._1924_promyshlennost.pdf [in Russian].
Protokol zasedanija soveta cenu zamestitelja narkoma vneshnej torgovli M.A. Loganovskogo «Proekt bjuro cen vsesojuznogo ob"edinenija Torgsin ob izmenenii cen na muchnye, krupjanye tovary i obuv'». 15 avgusta 1933 g. 1933 [Minutes of the meeting of the pricing council at the Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Trade M.A. Loganovsky's "Draft of the pricing bureau of the all-Union association Torgsin on changing prices for flour, cereals and footwear." August 15, 1933]. URL: https://istmat.org/node/42951 [in Russian].
Ruban, M. (2020). Do istorii reformuvannia zaliznychnoho transportu Ukrainy: rozvytok remontnoi bazy vahonnoho hospodarstva Donetskoi zaliznytsi (1925–1941) [A Story of the Reforms in the Ukraine’s Railway Transport: Building Repair Facilities of the Donetsk Railway Rolling-Stock Sector (1925–1941)]. Nauka ta naukoznavstvo 3(109). 116 - 130. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/sofs2020.03.116. [in Ukrainian].
Shitc, I.I. (1990). Dnevnik Velikogo pereloma [Diary of the Great Turning Point]. Paris:YMCA Press. 323 s. [in Russian].
Skubii, I. (2020). Woman consumption in Ukban Soviet Ukraine in 1920-1930s: between ideology and everyday life. History of retailing and consumption, 6(1). 30-44 [in English].
Specsvodka № 35 SOU OGPU i INFO OGPU o faktah otricatel'nogo haraktera no prompredprijatijam i rabochim rajonam na 9 avgusta 1930 g. [Special report No. 35 of the SOU OGPU and INFO OGPU on negative facts about industrial enterprises and workers’ districts on August 9, 1930]. URL: https://istmat.org/node/26185 [in Russian].
Spravochnik po util'syr'ju [Handbook of Recycling Materials]. (1931). Leningrad: SNAPKLLPGIZ [in Russian].
Statisticheskaja tablica CSU SSSR «Priobretenie obuvi i tkanej v sem'jah krest'jan v 1923/24, 1928/29, 1936, 1940, 1950, 1952 gg. i pervom polugodii 1953 g. (po dannym obsledovanija bjudzhetov)» [Statistical table of the Central Statistical Bureau of the USSR “Purchase of footwear and fabrics in peasant families in 1923/24, 1928/29, 1936, 1940, 1950, 1952 and the first half of 1953 (according to budget survey data)”]. 1953. URL: https://istmat.org/node/18415 [In Russian].
Sudrow, A. (2009). Der Schuh im Nationalsozialismus. Eine Produktgeschichte in Deutschland im Vergleich zu Großbritannien und den USA (1925 bis 1950). Wallstein Verlag. 877 p. [in German].
Tsentrálnyi derzhávnyi arkhív výshchykh órhaniv vlády ta upravlínnia Ukraíny (TsDAVO Ukrainy) [The Central State Archive of the Higher Authorities and Administration of Ukraine (TsDAVO of Ukraine)]
Tverdjukova, E. (2018). Antiservis: lichnyj avtomobil' i ego tehnicheskoe obsluzhivanie v SSSR (1960-e — 1980-e gg.) [Anti-service: the personal car and its maintenance in the USSR (1960s — 1980s)]. Novejshaja istorija Rossii, vyp. 8(3). 659-678. [in Russian].
Ustjuchenkov, V. (1933). Kozha iz novyh vidov syr'ja (plenki zheludka, serdechnye sumki, rog skota, shkury sudaka, shkury gusej) [Leather from new types of raw materials (stomach films, heart bags, cattle horns, pike perch skins, goose skins).]. Izdanie TEHPROPA SEVKAVKOZhTRESTA. Rostov na Donu. [In Russian].
Vihavainen, T., Bogdanova, E. (2016). Communism and Consumerism. The Soviet Alternative to Affluent Society. Leiden: Brill. 172 p. [in English].
Yankivska, O. (2014). Sotsialno-pobutova sfera zhyttia hromadian URSR yak vidbytok priorytetiv derzhavy vid pochatku povoiennoi vidbudovy do kintsia «vidlyhy» х Everyday life of UkrSSR citizens as a reflection of the priorities of the State from the beginning of post-war reconstruction to the end of the thaw]. Ukraina XX st.: kultura, ideolohiia, polityka: Zb. st., 19. 21-53. [in Ukrainian].
1917-1967, Uroven' zhizni, Zdravoohranenie, Naselenie [1917-1967, Standard of Living, Health Care, Population]. 1967. URL: https://istmat.org/node/17049 [In Russian].
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2024 Тетяна Перга